Showing posts with label CHC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CHC. Show all posts

Monday, 9 January 2017

Housing and Health a Link that is broken.

The link between Housing and Health is broken, severely limiting the lives of many our story is just one. 

 Background.

My husband contracted, through no fault of his own, a Staphylococcus infection in his neck in 2007, which crushed his spinal cord, leaving him as a high level (C3-C5) partial tetraplegic. I at the time had a fantastic career as an internationally based engineering project manager, my husband had semi-retired to support me in this. After being airlifted back to the UK, Hubby was placed in a Northern Spinal Injuries Unit. We were both treated so appallingly at this NHS unit we determined that the only way to maximise his recovery was to go private. We used our savings to ensure that he got the Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy that would maximise his chances of regaining some function. He went from being lucky if he got 2 x 20 minute sessions a week to having 5 sessions a day of different activities. We have since 2009, having used up our savings, transferred his outpatient care to the London NHS Spinal Injuries Unit who have been wonderful.

2009 we secured continuous health care funding for him. I thought this would mean that I would be able to return to work so that we could be masters of our own destiny.

Encountered Difficulties.


    • Standard / Quality of care provided in the community is not safe for someone with complex medical needs.
    • There are insufficient male care workers for disabled men that need intimate care tasks plus need to be physically moved on a regular basis for pressure sore prevention and relief.
    • The NHS like the local councils go for the cheapest they can get away with rather than the best fit for the disabled person. 
    • Our housing is a health and safety nightmare for care agencies to stand a remote chance of giving a decent service. 
    • Often trapped on first floor when very small lift out of service. 
    • Councils totally misunderstand the accessible housing needs of those with severe mobility issues and are placing people in totally unsuitable, unsafe housing. 
    • At National level the British Building regulations for wheelchair standard homes falls way short of the minimum space needs of those that use electric wheelchairs as more and more people do as they age with a disability. For Example, only making allowance for 1.2m turn away space from the end of a bed. Reference BS Part M[4](3b). 
    • The Disability Facilities Grant only allows for pure access issues and fails to legislate and therefore fund needs that are for medical reasons. For Example, extra bathroom for care worker use to prevent cross contamination, extra space for use of physio equipment.

The Result of Deficiencies.

  1. We have only had care provided for 5 months out of the last 84 months (7 years).
  2. Saving the NHS 7yrs x 100hrs/week care provision allocation = [gross cost £20/hr x 100 x 52 x 7] = £728k – care provided = £684k saving.
  3. I have lost more than £420k in potential earning income, my career is in tatters, my future financial security has been lost.
  4. My health as sole carer has suffered and I may well now need care myself in the not distant future due to the tremendous physical strain my body has endured physically lifting my husband in and out of his wheelchair due to the lack of space here and the hours that I need to be “on duty” as his needs 24/7 care.
  5. Hubby due to not having the space to use a tilt table has had more problems with his bowels and many more UTI’s than he could have had. He has lost even more function in his arms and hands that if he had had an accessible environment he would not have probably lost as he could have continued to do some things for himself. He is also very depressed as where he lives it is totally life limiting, isolating, too far away from his family and friends.

Tried to Help Ourselves.

Recognising that we need to first sort our housing situation so that we can fully engage / tackle compiling a care team we have done the following since 2009 without any success.
  • Got ourselves on the council waiting lists Spalding & Peterborough.
  • Contacted local charities and housing associations that specialise in accessible housing.
  • Made local politicians aware of our plight.
  • Looked at the HOLD scheme to see whether we could own our home.
  • Maintained contact with local council funded OT’s.
  • Worked with a not-for-profit organisation who said they would try and help.
  • Held numerous meetings with council officials trying to explain what we need.
  • Wrote and had a paper accepted for the parliamentary investigation into the built environment. October 2016.
Nothing we have done to try and help ourselves has resulted in us getting the help we urgently need.

NHS England could help more.

I note that there have been NHS monies made available for another disadvantaged group, those with learning difficulties which I am glad about as my eldest brother has a severe brain damage condition. May I please beg that those under the continuing health funding also need specialised help as everyone else is ignoring their plight. 
  1. Councils and Housing Associations seem to think their duty to the disabled is being fulfilled with the building of lifetime standard homes.
    • Most of these are totally unsuitable for those with higher mobility needs as it is very expensive to retrofit the extra space that an electric wheelchair user needs.
    • Bathrooms are too small for the specialised shower trolleys / recliner commodes used by those in the higher need category. We have calculated we need a minimum 2.5m x 2.5m footprint.
    • Most accommodation only has one bathroom, which means full shift care-workers have nowhere to change, wash separately after body fluid contamination and vice versa gives less protection to an immune compromised client. Also, means spouses / other family members are often denied the use of a bath.  

    • Most architects assume a double bed in a master bedroom when many require a hospital bed + single bed. This means that a master bedroom must be a minimum 4m x 4m (without storage) to allow for safe manoeuvre space by wheelchair, and safe working areas all around hospital bed by care-workers. The other bed needed by spouse or partner as most people do not get funding for full time coverage and need to make up the deficit in care coverage.

    • Extra care units always assume that people will be semi ambulant this is very clear in the way they always default to an abled-bodied kitchen and bathroom design rather making all accessible by wheelchair. Anything that needs to be retrofitted in our experience never gets done.
  2. Local hospitals are under extreme pressure to transfer patients back out into the community as soon as possible, despite the lack of suitable housing and community care.
  3. Care Homes and Nursing Homes are closing, leaving those with more specialised needs with the unpalatable choice of accepting sub-standard care for their needs or moving long distances away from their support networks.
  4. The national campaigns for the treatment of people with Alzheimer’s have been so successful that they are starting to affect the available options for those that do not have the disease. For example, ask clinicians or community care people regarding the dangers of Autonomic Dysreflexia and you will in most cases be met with a blank stare. 
NHS England therefore needs to keep the pressure up on all the agencies involved to ensure that extra care housing unit commissioners are considering the higher needs of the growing percentage population living longer in the community with complex health and disability challenges. Local Councils / Housing Associations need to be encouraged to work more closely with NHS bodies administrating the population that come under continuing health care. I recently attended a meeting of senior strategic housing people locally where they admitted that they have no idea of the actual housing needs of the people on their waiting lists, and that when people come under NHS CHC they have even less information, because social services are usually at arms length if involved at all.

It would be helpful for NHS England to develop template housing plans that would meet the needs of much of those with complex mobility & health needs; that these are disseminated widely among architects, housing associations, councils, etc. with of course lots of input from the disability community. 

This text has been sent by myself to NHS England so far no response. watch this space. 

Reply was along the lines, Housing is nowt to do with us. Well as long as you have that attitude you will always have people staying in hospital longer than you would like !!


<div align="center"><a href="http://www.carersclub.org" rel="nofollow" title="Carers Club"><img src="http://www.carersclub.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/logo@2x-1.png" alt="Carers Club" style="border: none; height: auto; width: 200px;" /></a></div>

Wednesday, 9 April 2014

Personal Budgets for those under NHS Funded Continuing Health Care.


On the surface having control over your own health budget is an attractive idea, after all politicians, clinicians have been trying to sell us the idea for quite some time now, as a way of taking some control over who we have looking after our loved ones. I say, beware of Greeks bearing gifts, ask yourself what is in it for them? I know that is a very cynical view of the world, but I have been bitten in the arse too many times by the system over the span of my lifetime to be anything other. 

Argument 1: It has been proven to work really well in social care.

Counter Argument : Patients under  Continuing Health Care have a proven on going medical need, their needs are usually complex , their care workers have to have specialised medical based knowledge. Who is going to certify that training, competency, on-going refreshers etc. If the patient’s family take on this role because they have decided to directly hire someone, this will be a mine field for both the family and the care worker.  Who will pay for the training? Only sensible other option will be to hire staff via an agency, so taking away the benefits of direct hire and higher wage for the care-worker.
Possible Outcomes: poorly trained care workers carrying out complex medical procedures, increase risk of adverse incidents or at best status quo.

Argument 2: Quality of Care workers can be improved as you can pay more.

Counter Argument: Yes it is true you do get what you pay for. Care workers are under paid for they do. Under the direct budget system you will probably have two ways of employing your care workers. Firstly directly employ the staff you need, this is not as easy as it sounds and although there are a few agencies that can do the pay roll side for you, which will come out of your budget. You become an employer responsible for insuring recruitment, National Insurance, rosters, annual leave cover, employment contracts, risk assessments, care plans, discipline and training are taken care of. I have an MBA, have run my own business, so understand all this stuff, I don’t relish taking this on.
The second way will be to recruit through a care worker agency, they will do all employers stuff for you, but you will still be responsible for negotiating the supply contract and because you will be a small customer you will not get the same deals that big organisations like the NHS negotiate.
Possible Outcomes: If you do it yourself and get it wrong, you could end up in court or employment tribunal. The papers are full of such stories of things going wrong. If you use an agency you could end up with contract conditions that are worse than the current ones under the superior buying power of the NHS. Benefit is that you take out the middleman and have a direct relationship with the agency.

Argument 3: The Budget.

How many families under continuing health care think they have a sufficient budget presently? Not many I would think. It has been made clear to me on several occasions that if my Hubby requires more than he is currently getting, he will be forced into a nursing home. This leaves me covering weekends, and any unexpected extra hours needed. So now you will be expected to take that already under funded budget and manage it yourself. How will it work under the new system if the patients requirements change how quickly will you be able to get the budget reallocated? In an emergency, i.e. all your staff fall ill with flu, weather prevents staff from getting there, you will be responsible for using your budget to cover this.  If managing the budget becomes too much, what mechanisms will be in place to have the NHS take things over again.
Possible Outcomes: Life is messy and so will this be.

Summary.

I have come to the conclusion that rather than improve what is not working well with the current system the NHS have jumped on personal budgets as a means of ridding themselves of a problem that they cannot be bothered to fix. 

Monday, 4 November 2013

Care in Crisis my take on things.

A Personal Critique of the Care Industry in the UK.

Firstly I must declare my interest in this subject, as the spouse of someone with severe mobility limitations, complex medical needs and the user of NHS sub contracted care workers. My husband qualified for Continuing fully funded NHS Health care at home in October 2009. Since this time I have been continually surprised and horrified at how broken the care system in the UK is. I have been left most of the time since that time to fend for myself as the system is so broken even for those that have a proven on going 24/7 medical need. Over the years we have been sent a 64year old female care-worker with advanced arthritis who thought she would just sit and be able to read a book on nights, a male care-worker with badly managed diabetes who could have gone into a coma any shift, care workers with so many social problems at home they could not concentrate at work, several care workers with horrendous personal hygiene, a care-worker who passed out with a massive heart attack looking panic attack whilst at work, care workers that did not understand how important time keeping and reliability are,  others that were not able to comprehend the complex medical theory needed to look after someone with a spinal injury, the list is endless and the whole experience has severely dented our faith in the UK care system.   
I am not writing this to knock those that work in the care industry. Many we have come across have been good people but just not in the right job. I also admit we are tough customers as we will not accept mediocrity and poor standards.  I can not, as I know my Husband’s life and long term survival is at stake. I therefore write this paper to point out what seems to be going wrong and add suggestions as to what can be done better.
Assessment of Clients.

The system at present, and this may change due to the planned joining up of social and health care, is that a person is allocated a social worker. These people are supposed to advise the client and family if there is such as to any care help that is needed. The assessment will grade the help needed, as moderate, high or critical. This is then either funded by the client or part/full funded by the council. At this stage council OT’s usually become involved as well. Many people needing help at home need equipment to help them. The local council will have contracts with various care providers, one of which will be dispatched to provide the amount of care that the council will have allocated to the client. As many news stories have highlighted this allocation is in many cases is woefully inadequate, leading to people having to choose between the toilet or a drink, 15 minute calls etc. If you are in the top need brackets of needing care you should be advised to try and get an assessment by the NHS under the fully funded Continuous Health Care provisions. Many people with dementia have had big problems getting through this assessment as their need often seems to fall under social need rather than medical need, which I know dementia organisations are fighting against at the moment. We were quite lucky in that my husband’s condition had been subject to court precedent ruling so our path through this horrendous assessment system was pretty much preordained. To pass this assessment you have to prove a need in several medical nursing areas, mobility, continence, cognition, behaviour, medicine management, to name a few. Once you have passed this you are not home and dry, then the battle begins on how much cover you will be provided and at what quality. We ended up compromising on the spread of hours covered with me theoretically taking up the slack at weekends and evenings, but still we got issued with social care qualified level staff that were totally inappropriate for a complex care case.  Getting nursing level qualified staff under this system is impossible unless there is a legal requirement to provide such as in ventilated cases. Again the NHS as their council counterparts tries to get away with the cheapest possible option, with very little attention paid to client need. We also found that the person we talked with at NHS in charge of our case, improved his career prospects with how much money he could shave off his budget, not the quality of service provided by his organisation. Once you qualify for NHS CHC you also lose your allocated social worker and have no one who is looking after your welfare and safety, the NHS allocated bod is a purse string holder and not interested in your welfare.  
This has left me astonished that having demonstrated an on-going medical need we have been allocated just above the minimum wage care workers, who with the best will in the world , would not be care workers if they had the training & education to be something else. A demonic, downward spiralling, vicious circle. The system is indeed in crisis and now I will make some suggestions as to how to fix it.

Fixing The Quality of Care-Workers.

Stage1: Recruitment.
The care industry could learn a lot from the rail industry. This industry has people working in some very safety critical roles, some earning minimum type wages some earning a professional type wage. Let’s take the case of the recruitment of a train driver, a comparable safety related job, with unsociable hours, a specific set of skills to learn and a great deal of personal responsibility. The only real difference being their remuneration, society seems value the job of a train driver more than that of someone we entrust our loved ones too, how bizarre is that?  To become a train driver you first have to pass a strict medical looking for drug, alcohol abuse, and general health failings. If only care companies did this for their employees, may be we would not have so many unhealthy smoking care workers in its ranks. Following on from the medical the potential driver then spends 2 days at an occupational psychometric testing centre, testing for concentration, learning ability, knowledge retention, quick reactions, personality, scenario testing and finally a one to one interview. Obviously not all of these types of tests would be appropriate for a care worker, but if the industry were to work with specialists in this area I am sure a set of tests could be devised to weed out unsuitable applicants. The trainee Drivers then go on theory of rail safety courses and of course on the job training. It seems to me that as long as potential care workers have a pulse can pass the criminal record checks many companies take them on. Until this stops and some professionalism is brought into the recruitment processes things will not change.

Stage 2: Training.
The training of care-workers does not seem to follow any recognised national standards and is left very much up to the private companies involved. This leads to a varying quality of standards, leaves care-workers without recognised qualifications and no clear career progression path. Until the training standards are modular , national and signed off by a recognised organisation such as the royal college of nursing or the like, variable standards in quality will remain.  

Stage 3: Career Progression.
For as long as being a care-worker is seen as a little bit above a cleaner and a chasm below a nurse, recruiting professionally minded people especially men to this industry will continue to fail. Care workers must have a similar possible career progression to those in the nursing profession and cross over between the lines of progression must be possible. I would suggest that the lowest level should be a social care worker, senior care worker, medical care worker, senior medical care worker, assistant community / district nurse, community / district nurse. All with the appropriate level of training equivalent to their hospital counterparts in the nursing professions.

Summary & Conclusion.
People in government need to get to grips with this, the industry must change or we will continue to hear about appalling cases of abuse, and neglect. I would contend it is not the answer to further dumb down this industry sector making it the purview of charities and volunteers. This sector needs to improve the quality of its offering not devalue it further by implying that any Tom, Dick, Theresa or Harriet can do it.  There is of course a place for volunteers and charities, they do indeed add a lot to the experiences of those that need social care, by providing auxiliary staff for care day centres, entertainment, education and the like.
Finally, I have deliberately steered away from discussing funding as I believe if we do not provide appropriate care for this generation that need care we have broken our contract with them. Many  paid their dues all their working lives with the expectation that they would be cared for in later life. Now the government may need to renegotiate the contract with the current people of working age out there, if they need to they need to get on with and quickly as none of us are getting any younger you know.


Angela Cavill-Burch (MBA NEBOSH MIRO)